The Matambre Challenge: Round One

The Matambre Challenge

Click Here For The Matambre Challenge Overview

Remember this is half fun and half research. The results of this challenge may not be indicative of whether or not these methods of preparation do what they are supposed to do. Sometimes you just get a poor quality cut of meat that nothing can defeat yet may work wonders for a high quality cut.

The Challengers In Round One Are:

  • Marinated in milk
  • Simmered in milk


Scored, seasoned with salt, and cooked on medium-low fire for about 20 minutes each side.

Marinated In Milk:

“That’s because you have to let it sit overnight in milk.” The reply I’ve received on occasion when mumbling to myself out loud about any tough piece of meat. Also, I’ve seen the direction to marinate matambre in milk from a few recipes out there in web world. I’ve used milk a few times to marinate calamari and sweetbreads and that worked wonders, but now is the time to see how it affects matambre. The meat is beef and the milk is from a cow so what the hay?

Low-fat milk was chosen. Better to just hit middle ground. Tossed it into a Ziploc® bag and let it sit for almost a day in the fridge. Upon removal from the milk I noticed that the meat retained much of its outer color compared to the grayish hues you get from other liquids–acidic or not. “Haha you can’t defeat me Mr. Milk.” I gave the meat a quick rinse and patted it down with some paper towels. Tossed it on the grill right next to the plain in order receive the same amount of heat and cooking time.

Simmered In Milk:

The 5-star milk bath spa treatment. I was never offered this method by word of mouth, however I did find it in a few recipes out there, particularly for matambre a la pizza (matambre that is topped like a pizza). Actually a commenter in the first challenge post pointed out this method for the pizza style as well.

I had an idea of what I was going to get into with this before actually trying it out with matambre. In the U.S., I sometimes did the quick and dirty way of boiling/simmering to create tender ribs slathered in bbq sauce when there wasn’t much time for a long smoke. (Purists, before you say anything, I know. I know. But remember I said quick and dirty. Not the right way.) With this method the bbq sauce helps in two ways. First, you keep the meat from drying out which can happen very quickly with boiled meat. Second, you can partially disguise the fact that you boiled the meat first. You won’t have that great smoky taste achieved by slow cooking, but you’ll have decent ribs that are at least tender and some people probably won’t know you boiled them first.

Ribs have bones and typically a good amount of fat all over the place. That keeps the meat moist in most parts no matter how you cook it. With matambre, you have an outer layer of fat on one side that is separated from the meat by a thin membrane. Also, there are no inner layers of fat or fat marbling. I knew that if this meat wasn’t going to be topped or basted with anything, I’d be in trouble. But, I wanted to try it anyway. No basting brine was planned for this round but maybe in the future.

In the pot I put 2 parts milk and 1 part water. I did this to prevent the pan from getting scorched on the bottom and that is not fun to clean when it happens. Even though I scored the meat, I was afraid the simmering might still cause some drastic curling. I decided to give it a nice simmer for an hour. Some recipes called for thirty minutes while others said 2 hours. Middle ground again. Fortunately curly did not happen much, only around the corners. However, as with all boiled meats, I ended up with a hideous, let’s not leave out grotesque, grayish-brown slab of stewed meat. As I moved it to the grill I thought to myself that this could become seriously parched. The meat needed a quick blast of heat on both sides to crisp it up a big notch in order to somewhat hide the fact that any precooking occurred. So this slice ended up with its own special area on the grill with an abundant amount of coals. About 8 minutes on each side.

Matambre Results

The Results:

The muscle fibers were making popping noises while chomping. Too bad, because the meat had a lot of flavor and was super juicy.

Marinated In Milk
The meat was much lighter on the outside than the plain. Looked almost like grilled pork. There wasn’t too much of a difference in taste compared to plain but I did detect a slightly richer flavor; that was a nice improvement. The marinating hardly took a bit out of the toughness. If plain was 0 and what I was looking for was 10, I’d give this method a 2.

Simmered In Milk
The parrilla performed a few magic tricks, just a few mind you, and gave our cranky ol matambre a slight makeover. The fatty side crisped up nicely while the other side did away with the gray and and achieved a nice brown. The meat was dry, no very dry, like eating sawdust. Pork tenderloin that has been overcooked is what I’d compare this to. The rubbery texture was defeated but juiciness was totally sacrificed.

Although the challengers failed to impress me, I won’t rule these two methods out for future use. The marinated in milk cut was just slightly better so it is possible that some tweaks can be made. Also, maybe if I basted the cut that was simmered with a brine solution the end result might not have been so dry. Some say to marinate and simmer in milk, so maybe I’ll give that a try too.

My wife asked me to me if I was going to give up. No no no, the fun has just begun. Till next time…

If you think this may benefit others, please share with your favorite social site:
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Live
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz